Critique-Revision MCP Server

An MCP server for evaluating ideas for flaws and then refining them through a structured critique-revision process.

Overview

The Critique-Revision server provides a structured approach to improving ideas through a two-phase process:

1. Critique Phase: Systematically evaluate an idea to identify specific flaws, weaknesses, or areas for improvement
2. Revision Phase: Refine the original idea by addressing the identified flaws and making targeted improvements

This approach is particularly useful for:

• Improving the quality and robustness of proposals or solutions
• Identifying potential issues before implementation
• Refining ideas through multiple iterations
• Testing assumptions and identifying weaknesses
• Quality assurance for important decisions

Features

• Systematic critique of ideas from multiple perspectives
• Identification of specific flaws with severity assessment
• Structured revision process to address identified issues
• Tracking of improvement areas and addressed flaws
• Support for multiple critique-revision cycles
• Confidence assessment for critiques
• Final revision status tracking

Usage

Installation

npm install -g @cognitivegraphai/critique-revision

Running the Server

npx @cognitivegraphai/critique-revision

API

The server provides the following actions:

createIdea

Create a new idea to be critiqued and revised.

{
  "action": "createIdea",
  "ideaId": "idea-123",
  "ideaContent": "The content of the idea to critique and revise"
}

createCritique

Create a critique of an idea, identifying specific flaws.

{
  "action": "createCritique",
  "critiqueData": {
    "ideaId": "idea-123",
    "ideaContent": "The content of the idea being critiqued",
    "critiqueId": "critique-456",
    "critiqueFocus": "Feasibility",
    "critiqueMethod": "Cost-benefit analysis",
    "flawsIdentified": [
      "Requires too many resources",
      "Timeline is unrealistic"
    ],
    "severityLevel": "Medium",
    "confidenceLevel": "High",
    "critiqueNumber": 1,
    "totalCritiques": 3,
    "needsRevision": true
  }
}

createRevision

Create a revision of an idea based on a critique.

{
  "action": "createRevision",
  "revisionData": {
    "revisionId": "revision-789",
    "parentCritiqueId": "critique-456",
    "originalIdeaId": "idea-123",
    "revisionContent": "The revised content addressing the identified flaws",
    "addressedFlaws": [
      "Requires too many resources",
      "Timeline is unrealistic"
    ],
    "improvementAreas": [
      "Resource allocation",
      "Project timeline"
    ],
    "revisionNumber": 1,
    "totalRevisions": 2,
    "isFinalRevision": false
  }
}

getIdeaDetails

Get details about an idea and its critiques.

{
  "action": "getIdeaDetails",
  "ideaId": "idea-123"
}

getCritiqueDetails

Get details about a critique and its revisions.

{
  "action": "getCritiqueDetails",
  "critiqueId": "critique-456"
}

getRevisionDetails

Get details about a revision and its parent critique.

{
  "action": "getRevisionDetails",
  "revisionId": "revision-789"
}

getCritiqueRevisionChain

Get the complete chain of critiques and revisions for an idea.

{
  "action": "getCritiqueRevisionChain",
  "ideaId": "idea-123"
}

License

MIT