@ian-pascoe/pi-minimal-subagents
v0.16.0
Published
Persistent nested subagents with bounded delegation for Pi
Readme
Minimal Subagents
Install and load
Install the package from npm:
pi install npm:@ian-pascoe/pi-minimal-subagentsInstalling the Git collection enables every extension in the repository:
pi install git:github.com/ian-pascoe/pi-extensionsTo select only Minimal Subagents from that Git package, set its extension
filter in ~/.pi/agent/settings.json using the repository-relative path:
{
"packages": [
{
"source": "git:github.com/ian-pascoe/pi-extensions",
"extensions": ["packages/pi-minimal-subagents/src/index.ts"]
}
]
}From this package checkout, load the source directly with
pi -e ./src/index.ts. Requires Node >=22.19.0 and Pi >=0.99.0.
Typical workflow
subagentlaunches a Child Agent from a self-contained task: by default the child starts without the parent's conversation. It returns at once with itsagent_id,turn_id, and resolved model, thinking level, tools, delegation, and any tool-resolutionwarnings. Spawns run sequentially, so asubagent_waitoragent_messagein the same tool batch can target the new child.subagent_waitclaims the turn's result, or leave it unclaimed and the final response arrives automatically as a steer message. Withoutturn_id, a wait skips turns whose result you already claimed or received automatically, and never repeats an automatically delivered result: it reportsalready_delivered: trueinstead of the output.agent_messagecontinues an idle child: the result reportsdisposition: "started-turn"with the newturn_id. A plainsubagent_wait({ agent_id })targets that new turn, not the first result; passturn_idto re-read a turn whose result is still retained, claimed or not.subagent_statusinspects children;subagent_cancelstops work but keeps the session;subagent_deleteremoves it. Deleted IDs cannot be reused, and spawning with an existingagent_idfails with that child's state and the next step (agent_message,subagent_delete, or anotheragent_id).
Configuration
Configure the extension in Pi's standard settings files:
- global:
~/.pi/agent/settings.json - project:
./.pi/settings.json, when the project is trusted
Project values override global values. Run /reload after editing either file.
Subagent Access
minimalSubagents.enabled controls whether the six Root Agent Coordinator
Tools start active. It defaults to true; a trusted project value overrides
the global value.
{
"minimalSubagents": {
"enabled": false
}
}Use /subagents to inspect or change access without editing JSON:
/subagents
/subagents status
/subagents enable|disable|reset
/subagents enable|disable|reset --global
/subagents enable|disable|reset --projectBare /subagents means status. Unscoped changes apply to the selected
session-tree branch. reset removes that override and follows project, global,
then the built-in default. Scoped changes update both the selected branch and
the chosen settings file; project changes require a trusted project. A malformed
settings file is left unchanged and reported with its path.
Disabling Subagent Access removes all six Coordinator Tools from the Root
Agent while preserving unrelated tools. It does not cancel or alter existing
Child Agents, their Launch Contracts or fanout capability, Coordination Message
delivery, or terminal-result delivery. Reload and resume preserve the selected
branch override, /tree restores the newly selected branch, forks inherit the
source branch, and a new branch without an override follows settings.
Model roles
minimalSubagents.modelRoles gives the parent agent named, advisory choices of
eligible models. The extension defines no roles itself, performs no task
classification, and does not route launches: the parent names the role it wants
with the optional role argument of subagent.
{
"minimalSubagents": {
"modelRoles": {
"budget": "opencode-go/glm-5.2:low",
"design": {
"model": "opencode-go/kimi-k3:high",
"hint": "UI design, visual critique, and frontend polish"
}
}
}
}A recognized final suffix (off, minimal, low, medium, high, xhigh,
or max) is the role's thinking_level, not part of the canonical model.
Unsuffixed roles leave thinking selection independent: the child uses the
caller's thinking level unless thinking_level is passed.
Role names and hints are trimmed, single-line text. Names may be up to 64
characters and hints up to 500 characters. Models use canonical
provider/model IDs and must be available under the effective enabledModels
scope. The resolver matches the complete authored model ID first, so real
colon-bearing IDs—including IDs ending in :high—remain exact model IDs;
only an otherwise-unmatched recognized final suffix is treated as a thinking
preference. A thinking level pinned in enabledModels neither supplies nor
constrains a role preference, and normal spawn-time model-capability clamping
still applies.
Launching with a role
subagent({ task, role: "design" }) launches the child with the design role's
model and, when the role has a suffix, its thinking level. An explicit model or
thinking_level overrides the role's value independently, so
{ role: "design", thinking_level: "low" } keeps the role's model with a
different thinking level. The role is recorded even when explicit model and
thinking_level override all of its values. An unknown role fails before any
child is created and lists the configured role names. The Launch Contract
records the resolved model and thinking_level together with the role used
(role is absent when none was named), and subagent_status and the expanded
subagent result show it. Recording the name does not tie the child to the role: later settings
changes never alter an existing Launch Contract.
Roles are read when the session starts, so editing modelRoles mid-session
changes nothing until a reload. The role parameter is a plain string rather
than an enum of the configured names, so the tool definition stays
byte-identical when modelRoles changes. Only the role list in the system
prompt (the subagent prompt guidelines) changes, and only at reload. The
model enum is separate: it already follows the eligible models.
Global and project roles merge by name in settings order. Expanded role
objects merge by field; a project string replaces the whole global entry. A
project can remove one inherited role with null, or clear all inherited
roles by setting modelRoles to null.
{
"minimalSubagents": {
"modelRoles": {
"budget": null
}
}
}Invalid or unavailable entries are omitted. The extension emits one consolidated startup warning and keeps every valid role.
Maximum delegation depth
minimalSubagents.maxSubagentDepth is a positive safe integer. It counts
subagent levels beneath the interactive root: 1 permits root children, 2
also permits grandchildren, and so on. The default is 2.
{
"minimalSubagents": {
"maxSubagentDepth": 1
}
}A trusted project value replaces the global value. Project null restores
the built-in default of 2. An invalid project value emits a warning and
leaves a valid global value in effect.
Reloading with a lower depth does not delete existing agents or change their
launch contracts. Before /reload invalidates the old extension runtime, the
extension waits for active child and root work to settle, then disposes idle
child runtimes. A deliberately non-settling agent can therefore delay reload
indefinitely. The new limit controls restored tool availability and future
spawn attempts; the root retains recursive hierarchy management.
Toolsets
Configure ordinary tools using case-sensitive minimatch pattern strings. For example:
{
"minimalSubagents": {
"baseToolset": ["context_*"],
"readToolset": ["read", "grep", "find", "ls"],
"modifyToolset": ["bash", "edit", "write", "lsp_*", "dap_*"]
}
}The defaults are baseToolset: [],
readToolset: ["read", "grep", "find", "ls"], and
modifyToolset: ["bash", "edit", "write"]. Each configured array replaces that
key's inherited value; [] clears it. Omitted keys inherit the global value or
built-in default. Only trusted project settings apply.
Tool Presets are cumulative:
tools: "read": Base Toolset +readToolset.tools: "modify": Base Toolset +readToolset+modifyToolset.tools: "none"ortools: []: Base Toolset only.tools: ["read"]: Base Toolset + exactlyread; arrays do not expand patterns or presets.- Omitted
tools: Base Toolset + the caller's Reachable Tools: the Root Agent's active tools plus tools scripts can call without declaring them (codemodeordeferredexposure, such as MCP tools), or a Child Agent caller's own grant.
Patterns select from permitted ordinary tool names, including inactive tools registered at the root. Their matches are unioned in pattern order, retaining registry order within each pattern and removing duplicates at first occurrence. Each pattern is independent: a negated minimatch pattern matches its complement; it does not subtract earlier matches. Coordinator Tools remain separately controlled by delegation.
Invalid configuration entries and patterns matching no permitted ordinary tools warn and are skipped. Configured tools unavailable in child resources are also skipped with a warning, rather than blocking launch. Explicit and inherited tool requests remain strict. A child never gains capabilities beyond its parent's ceiling, including when a restored parent predates a newly configured Base Toolset. Use status to inspect the concrete grant if an optional plugin is absent.
Pattern expansion happens when a Child Agent is created. /reload applies
settings to future launches without changing existing Launch Contracts. If a tool
in an existing contract later disappears, normal restoration dependency checks
still apply; the saved grant is not silently rewritten. Toolsets configure names,
not tool operations: granting a multifunction tool grants that tool's available
operations, regardless of preset name.
Child Agents load Pi's built-in llama.cpp, codemode, tool-search, and mcp
extensions unless settings disable them (-builtin:<name>); each child connects
its own MCP servers. Pi does not export the llama.cpp factory, so children load it
from Pi's installed dist/extensions/llama/index.js; when that file is absent, a
llama.cpp launch model is reported as a missing dependency. Child codemode
scripts get no models API, so they cannot call models outside the Launch
Contract. A tool's exposure still decides whether it is declared or reachable only
through codemode or tool_search. Granted codemode- or deferred-exposed
tools are callable but not declared, so a child that needs them also needs
codemode or tool_search in its grant. Ungranted tools are unreachable in the
child. MCP tools are checked at launch only by name, because children register
them after connecting; a tool whose server disappeared fails when called. Closing
a child runtime shuts its extensions down, closing its MCP connections. A reopened
child re-declares the tools it last declared itself, including tools loaded
through tool_search; as in Pi, a tool that registers only after the child opens,
such as an MCP tool, is not re-declared. Declarations inherited from the parent's
context are not restored.
Capabilities and persistence
Child sessions are persistent Pi sessions. Their launch contracts bound model, tool, project-context, session-context, delegation, and depth capabilities at creation; reloading does not silently broaden them. The default maximum depth is two levels beneath the interactive Root Agent.
The extension registers six coordinator tools for the Root Agent and fanout
children below the depth cap: subagent, agent_message, subagent_wait, subagent_status,
subagent_cancel, and subagent_delete. Children that cannot spawn (delegation
none, or fanout at the depth cap) have no children to wait on or inspect, so they
receive only agent_message.
A running child's latest_activity_at advances with the timestamps of its latest
messages and tool results. Targeted subagent_status includes recent_activity, a bounded tail of message
text, reasoning, tool calls, and tool results. It includes the current streaming
assistant message but omits image data. Timeout Wait Events carry only a compact
progress snapshot. Children target only direct children; the Root Agent
may inspect any descendant. Model-facing status reports a child_count but no
nested children summaries. Reported usage always includes cacheWrite1h
and reasoning, as 0 when the provider reports none. Tool-result text and
structuredContent round every usage.cost field to six decimal places of USD;
exact values stay in session data. subagent_cancel
lists in affected_agent_ids only agents whose active turns it cancelled.
session_context defaults to omit: the child starts with only its system
prompt and task, so the task should be a self-contained brief covering the goal,
target files and non-goals, the change or question, and acceptance criteria.
Opt in to inherit to copy the parent's conversation, or compact to summarize
it first, only when the child needs that discussion. Inheriting is costly: the
child's system prompt differs from its parent's, so the copied conversation
cannot reuse the parent's prompt cache, and compact adds a summarization call.
With either opt-in, the parent's conversation is quoted rather than replayed as
the child's own turns: each parent message becomes one
minimal-subagents.parent-context custom message, sent to the model as
user-role text wrapped in <parent_message from="…" role="…">. Tool calls and
results become text, a custom message's label names its customType, and an
errored, aborted, or length-limited parent turn is marked as incomplete. Images
are kept; parent reasoning and the parent's system prompt and tool declarations
are omitted, since the child declares its own. Each quoted message stays a
separate session entry, so compact can still summarize older entries. The task
is then framed as a handoff: the quoted conversation is background, its requests
belonged to the parent, and the child's own assignment follows. Quoting keeps
the parent's turns distinct from the child's own; it does not guarantee that a
child, particularly a small model, ignores the quoted requests. Existing Child Agents keep the mode recorded in their Launch Contracts.
The subagent tools argument distinguishes configurable Tool Presets from
exact lists; every selection also receives the permitted Base Toolset described
above. Coordinator tools are injected separately according to delegation and
must not appear in explicit tools arrays; misuse returns an actionable error.
Child sessions load the Root Agent's
configured settings and extensions, excluding the recursive
pi-minimal-subagents entrypoint. Project Context controls only project-scoped
AGENTS instructions and skills; omitting it retains user instructions and
skills plus project settings, extensions, providers, and tools. A configured
pi-codex-conversion adapter replaces a complete granted tool group only,
including the "read" preset's read, grep, find, and ls tools. Exact
tool arrays are replaced only when they contain the complete source group.
Because Codex performs discovery through exec_command, an adapted "read"
preset is not an enforced read-only boundary. Status reports effective adapter
tools while the Launch Contract continues to record the originally granted
capability names.
agent_message reports whether a message was delivered through an active
parent wait (delivered-via-wait), queued into the recipient's active turn
(queued), started a new turn on an idle child (started-turn, with its
turn_id), or failed. A failed delivery and a
partially failed subagent_delete return an error result (isError: true) that
still carries the declared structured output, so the model sees an error while
codemode scripts receive the failures or error data instead of a data-less
rejection. subagent_wait can return an
intermediate Wait Event containing a Coordination Message before the child turn
settles. That event claims only its message, so later unconsumed messages and the
terminal result retain automatic fallback. If the turn has already settled, a
wait returns its terminal result with queued messages in messages; waiting
again for a settled turn you claimed returns the same result while it is
retained. Pass optional turn_id to address a retained turn exactly, including
one whose result you already claimed (a claimed result stays retained until
Delivery Evidence settles it). Without it, waits skip claimed turns and turns
whose result was already delivered to you automatically, and select the oldest
remaining observable turn, falling back to the active, then latest, turn. When
that fallback reaches a result already delivered to you automatically, whether
still queued or settled, the wait returns event: "turn" with
already_delivered: true, the turn identity, and status, but no output; it does
not claim the turn, and turn_id rereads the full result. A
caller may have only one outstanding wait for the same source turn; a
concurrent duplicate is rejected instead of competing for one Wait Event.
When timeout_ms expires, the wait returns an observational event: "timeout"
with the requested turn identity and a compact, bounded progress snapshot
(state, elapsed_ms, latest_activity_at, total_tokens, and the labels of
the last three Recent Activity items as recent_activity_labels), under about 1 KB. It omits the task and
Launch Contract; targeted subagent_status returns the full detail.
It removes only the waiter, leaving the child
running and all pending delivery unclaimed. Abort signals remain errors.
The persisted Delivery Ledger records Coordination Messages, terminal results, globally increasing sequence, and wait ownership before delivery. Existing items retain their sequence; gaps from skipped malformed records are valid. Claims can name only active, latest, or retained turns. Wait-returned messages retain individual delivery evidence; terminal wait ownership remains durable across reloads, forks, and newer turns. Automatic fallback retains its ordered queue reservation while batching queued messages from one source turn into one Pi steer. Root-bound messages remain batchable while the root turn is active; a pending terminal result absorbs them. If Pi discards a root-bound steer before consuming it, as Esc does, the next root turn boundary reporting an empty Pi queue releases the result: a default wait selects it again at once, and automatic fallback re-sends it, ahead of newer results, into the root run if it is still going, or, after an abort such as Esc, when the root's next run starts. Recovery never starts a root turn by itself. Child sessions drain all available steers before the next model call. Destination-session Delivery Evidence still settles each batched ledger item independently, preventing duplicate delivery and unbounded checkpoint growth. The pure Delivery Ledger state machine retains at most 20 pending wait-only terminal results per source agent; Coordination Messages are not removed by that terminal-retention limit. Delivered messages include stable delivery, source-agent, and source-turn identities in persisted details.
Deleting a child first verifies its session header and persistent identity,
then uses the optional trash command when available and falls back to
unlinking its session file. Deletion prunes pending delivery state and retained
recent-message projections sourced from the complete deleted subtree. Restore
and clone perform the same ownership check against the recorded child-session
leaf. Restoration loads metadata and validates saved sessions without starting
child runtimes or their extension services (including MCP Servers). Status,
saved transcripts, settled-result waits, cancellation of idle children, and
session management do not start runtimes. A message or an undelivered child-bound
result opens only its recipient's runtime on demand; saved Delivery Evidence
prevents already-delivered work from reopening it. Runtime initialization errors
are reported when that child is first needed.
Registry replay and Delivery Evidence are scoped to the Root Agent's active
session-tree branch. Registry writes use V2 records with complete field,
identity, sequence, hierarchy, adjacency, destination, ordinary-tool ceiling,
and coordinator-tool exclusion validation. Every available V2 agent has a
selected leaf; only unavailable recovery placeholders may omit it. Valid V1
records and checkpoints migrate during replay; invalid owned records are
skipped with semantic diagnostic codes rather than disabling the extension.
Persisted message activity carries an explicit recorded_at from the
coordinator clock.
/tree abandons old process-local work and restores the selected branch. Fork
preparation is read-only; only confirmed fork shutdown interrupts work and
clones the selected branch, so another extension can cancel a fork without
freezing coordinator tools. Each clone records a new generation-specific
identity/provenance pair, and the destination appends ownership for that clone's
current session ID rather than reusing inherited ownership. If a
process-local fork handoff is lost, recovery reads only the destination's
selected branch and proceeds only when its canonical parentSession proves the
source file; it never substitutes the source session's newer head.
Tool annotations
The coordinator tools declare MCP-style annotations, which Pi reports through pi.getAllTools() for permission extensions and does not send to model providers. subagent is destructive and open-world because a Child Agent can use any tool it is granted. agent_message is not read-only but is non-destructive and closed-world. subagent_cancel is non-destructive and idempotent; subagent_delete is destructive and idempotent. subagent_status and subagent_wait are read-only (subagent_wait consumes queued deliveries, so it is not idempotent).
Status and TUI
Coordinator tool calls and results stay readable without expanding. A
subagent call shows the launch settings the caller chose and its task; an
agent_message call shows its message. While subagent_wait blocks, it shows
the child's tool-call count and, on a tree rail, the latest work of the turn
being waited on, rendered with Pi's own message and tool components as in the
/subagents viewer and refreshed each second; collapsed, the rail keeps the
newest items within 20 lines. A settled wait shows the child's output as
Markdown, or its error, with duration, tokens, and cost. Long text previews its
first 10 lines, like Pi's read. Every collapsed result ends its first line
with Pi's tool-expansion hint (normally Ctrl+O), which reveals the rest and the
full detail. Automatic agent results and messages preview the same way.
In TUI mode, /subagents or /subagents status opens a large, centered,
framed overlay. Up/Down selects a Child Agent; Enter opens its Child Session
Transcript. Escape returns to the tree, then Escape closes the overlay. The
viewer is read-only: Root Agent input and ongoing agent work remain intact.
Two consecutive Left Arrow presses within 500 ms open the same viewer when the main editor is focused and completely empty. Drafts (including whitespace), dialogs, and other overlays retain normal navigation. Explicit key-repeat reports are ignored; legacy terminals cannot distinguish holding Left from two presses.
The viewer and compact widget prioritize sibling subtrees containing running Child Agents. Idle ancestors move with active descendants, parents stay above their children, and equally active siblings retain their original order. Viewer selection follows the Child Agent's identity through live reordering.
The transcript includes inherited context, earlier turns, pre-compaction messages, and live output on the selected saved branch. Abandoned branches and internal bookkeeping are excluded. Saved history can be inspected without restoring a runtime; missing or unverified sessions report an explanation rather than substituting another branch. Model-facing Recent Activity remains bounded.
Transcripts open at the latest output and refresh once per second. Up/Down scrolls by line, Page Up/Page Down by page. Scrolling up pauses following; End returns to live output. Reading position is retained through resize and tool expansion. Reasoning is visible, tool output starts collapsed, and Pi's configured tool-expansion key (normally Ctrl+O) reveals it. Images appear as explicit text placeholders rather than inline images.
The tree header reports the effective access source, authored settings, direct
running/idle counts, and actual Coordinator Tool activation. Partial external
activation is reported as N/6 active; status does not repair it.
RPC mode receives a concise status notification. JSON and print modes produce no observer-only output.
Visible Child Agent rows show the canonical provider/model:thinking Runtime
Profile. Status uses the live Runtime Profile while a runtime exists and falls
back to the immutable Launch Contract otherwise. Live changes are observational:
they do not rewrite persistence or change nested spawn defaults.
